Re-evaluating Christmas during this week may seem unnecessary to you, and even pointless, but with the constant pressure to commercialize what was originally set aside as a day of worship and celebration, the need to regularly assess is incredible! Over the years, I've tried to be diligent to direct our activities toward the sacred, but it's amazing how quickly things can slide back to the secular. (Please note that I am aware Christmas was originally set aside by the early church on a pagan holiday, but nothing in scripture prohibits us from honoring God on any given day - Romans 14:5,6.)
Circumstances beyond our control can also throw off regular holiday patterns. Illness, travel, grief (due to a loved one's passing), and unusual life events disrupt our normal routines. God certainly allows these times in our life to serve His purposes and He uses them to refine us, but that does not mean that we shouldn't be purposeful and diligent about focusing our activities during the holiday season in order to make sure the time is mostly spent on the important and not just the urgent.
During this week of relatively "quiet" moments, set aside some time to discuss Christmas 2011 with your spouse and family members. If you're not purposeful in handling holiday choices, you'll be thrust from event to event and end up feeling very dissatisfied spiritually... which is to miss the point of Christmas!
Although you may not agree with how John Piper's family handles Christmas, I highly recommend that you read his article How We See Christmas Symbols. He discusses not only how they handle Santa Claus, but how they decorate during the holidays and why. At the very least, it will help you to get started thinking why you do what you do at Christmas!
How To Re-evaluate Christmas
Tips reposted from August 31, 2010: Evaluating Christmas
1. Get your spouse on board. Share your heart and be willing to compromise. It might not come as passionately to all the members of your family, especially if you have a spouse who is like a grown up kid at Christmas! Don't get frustrated, just ask that the family consider making one change this Christmas and see how everyone likes it.
2. Evaluate your Christmas values together as a family. Do not skip this step! If you do, you'll likely miss what is really important to your family. Be sure to ask questions such as:
• What is the most important thing that you want your family to do to in order to truly celebrate Christ's birth?
• What is hindering you from celebrating?
• What puts a damper on the season?
• What truly gives you satisfaction at Christmas time?
• When do you feel you've worshiped the most during past Christmases?
• What traditions meant the most to you as a child?
• What current activities do you have that your children will call traditions?
• Are these the traditions you want for your family?
• What is missing that you feel needs to be included?
• What do you wish you could eliminate this year if you knew it wouldn't hurt anyone's feelings?
• If there is a family obligation that cannot be eliminated, how can you interject something into the situation that would make it better for everyone?
3. Pray. Based on your evaluation, you will start to camp out on something that you know in your heart needs to be changed. It might be the most difficult thing on your list, but it's bugging you the most. Ask God if this is the thing that you need to change this year. And if it's not this, then ask Him to show you what He would have you do.
4. Form a plan. After you've spent some time in prayer, start planning how you will implement your new priority. This, too, will require prayer! Most likely, something will need to be eliminated in order to add something in. How will you handle that? How will you notify family? How can you make it sound as positive as it really is? Think this through carefully.
5. Schedule it if necessary. Put it on the calendar. If it's baking cookies, set aside a day to gather supplies and another day to do the activity. If it's building an outdoor nativity together, block off a weekend.
6. Contact those it affects. Family pow-wow. A phone call. Email. Whatever it is, don't wait until too late or you might have hard feelings. People need time to adjust to new things. This doesn't mean they are rejecting your idea, they just need time to get use to it. If it involves less gifts, it is courteous to notify family in advance, before purchases are made. And if it requires a change in family plans, this is a must!
7. Re-evaluate after Christmas. This is highly important!
Did it meet your expectations?
Did if flop?
Was it awkward?
Was it a hit?
Who loved it and who didn't? Why?
Was it just 'new' and needs to be tried again next year?
What changes would make it better?
Would you do it again?
What would you like to add next year?
8. Write it down. I keep a Christmas notebook so that I will remember things from year to year. While you may remember the wonderful time you had, you may forget the details that made it so successful. Be sure to include notes for changes next year.
9. Follow up and thank family. Be sure to express your gratitude for those who had to be flexible. Let them know how your family was blessed by the changes and find out if they were pleased as well.
10. Begin thinking of next year. Be in prayer and open to the Holy Spirit for how you can continue to make changes each year. Your family will grow and change and your activities each year will need to adjust as well. As children grow and get married, their spouses will come with traditions of their own. Working in a spirit of love and developing communication now will lay a foundation for working with new members in years to come.
What are some changes you plan to make for Christmas 2012?


We have re-evaluated Christmas in the past couple of years, since we no longer have any children at home. We made the decision to withdraw completely from any Christmas festivities and focus on simply praising Christ and prayer. We no longer exchange gifts with anyone, have a huge family meal with many people or even have a tree. All of these things cause more stress and help to ruin what could be a wonderfully, quiet, praising time!
ReplyDeleteSociety's idea of what the "Holidays" entail has gotten completely out of hand. We have withdrawn, partly, in rebellion against what it has become.
We really enjoy all of the holidays and the break from work now, with a simple dinner on Christmas day for 4-6 of us! Nothing more. No feverish shopping and stressing about what to get people that will equal what we are getting and the need to provide everyone with anything they could possibly want to eat that day. We don't attend parties and festivities with people who are only acquaintances, at best.
We only wonder why we didn't do this earlier!
Hi Amy, a timely post - this year my husband and I had decided to really tone down Christmas at our home.
ReplyDeleteJust a very small tree, more visiting with friends and neighbours and more time spent in reflection.
It's been quite wonderful! I hope your family had a wonderful Christmas.
My husband and I struggle with this a lot. We both have multiple family events to juggle on each side, and because his parents are both divorced and remarried it makes it even more hectic and complicated. We end up feeling so frazzled from running around crazy trying to not leave anybody out but something has got to give! I want our Christmas to be about worshipping Christ, reflecting on our blessings and helping those in need but unfortunately I felt more empty this year on Christmas day than ever. We. don't even have kids yet! How do you go about cutting out or changing a family event without really hurting or offending someone? Thank you for this wonderful post.
ReplyDeleteChristmas has just begun for us. It starts December 25 and ends this year on Sunday, January 8. Merry Christmas!
ReplyDeletei do believe i try something new each year. ever since we got married in 2004 ...adjusting how we each celebrate Christmas. as well as adjusting how each family celebrates Christmas. considering both families are not living close. we are within the same state ...but not next door. it's tough to make everyone happy. i'm thinking that after a few years we will get the hang of things ...but it's tough because we always worry that we are not making one of the families as happy as the other. i thank you for your post because it's something everyone should think about & consider. i will continue to attack (or think) on this very subject. the main difference that happened this year one family member wanted to not give gifts because of money concerns (trying to save). we were happy about it all but you felt the others were not so happy. with change there is progress ... progress causes change. it's all good. (:
ReplyDeleteI've been thinking along these lines. This year-- we (the Husband and I) gave homemade Christmas presents. That is our *new* thing for this year. #1. It was budget friendly for us.
ReplyDelete#2 Our Grands receive an over abundance to the point that our own grown Children--are overwhelmed with the influx of toys and the like.
#3 We thought out our gifts and gave consumable, what we thought to be useful items (this year was fruit baskets that included assorted homemade flavored popcorn and crackers,for the Grands... crocheted hats, slippers or scarves)
Over all I think it went pretty well. All the gifts were well received. I never ever felt pressure to compete; because I knew in my heart this was what was right for us!
I plan to do the same or similar this year in the way of gifts. For our own home-- I'm praying about not having the tree; instead I'd just like to have an advent wreath and candles. Along with the Nativity that we always display at Christmas.
You've given lots to think about and I also enjoyed reading the J.Piper article as well. The scripture reference from Romans was the most helpful-- thank you.
Hope you have a great start to a Wonderful new year!
Pat
Another wise post, Amy! Thank you! This was an odd Christmas for us in that I was nauseous and tired for the months of Nov and Dec due to my pregnancy, so we did hardly anything to celebrate. It was a very simple, stripped down Christmas season for us. What was interesting was that as we've not done the normal holiday stuff we've always done, I've thought a lot about what I've missed and what I haven't missed; what value was lost or not lost; what would have been helpful for my kids or what didn't matter. It's got me thinking for next year already...we're definitely doing advent candles again, and we're definitely doing our Jesse Tree advent w/ ornaments for the month of December--that was so rich last year for our kids, and I greatly missed it this year. I wasn't anticipating that a very simple, low-key Christmas would cause me to re-evaluate, but it really has been a helpful Christmas season. I think next year will be richer, more meaningful and more Christ-centered because of it.
ReplyDeleteThis is really great....I know that the Christmas season can become very taxing on some people...from finances to depression. There are ways to free us from these heavy demands that we place upon ourselves....I think it should be a family affair and not left up to one or perhaps a few to do everything...
ReplyDeleteThis is a very good post and I plan to read and re-read.
Thanks for sharing..
shug
Thank you for sharing this timely post, Amy! Spending an evening (or more) discussing and reevaluating how we celebrate the Christmas holiday is certainly in order -- reformed and always reforming. :)
ReplyDeleteBlessings to you and yours in the new year!
~Lisa
A timely and needed post for us. Many thanks Amy for this organized approach. Blessings~ Laura
ReplyDeleteThank-you Amy for your thoughtful post. We are jewish believers so Channukah has mostly been our focus but we have a tree every year that we just can't seem to give up! The solution for 2012 is to have a tree with homemade ornaments inscribed with all the prophecies of Yeshua's birth. We will spend the year studying these prophecies.
ReplyDeleteWe do give gifts for the 8 nights of Channukah but they are small and home made. It is a celebration of rededication and miracles so acknowledging G-d's greatest gift for us is a part of the season as well.
One of the special things about Christmas is about spending time with the ones that you care about and love, i try and not pay attention to anything else now. Even the new Christmas commercials are nothing like when we were kids growing up in the 1960s and 70s. Happy new years to you. Richard
ReplyDeleteI checked my Santa that is similar to yours and it is a Rushton. Mine has fabric hands and is missing some of it's costume- the belt and what appears to be a vest or coat. I found a photos of it on line at http://www.worthpoint.com/worthopedia/rushton-star-creation-santa-claus-figure-w-gold
ReplyDelete