My brain is so full of great information that I've gleaned from reading Fruitless Fall that I hope I can articulate some thoughts in a meaningful manner here on the blog. I don't want to spoil it for those reading the book, but I am a bit impatient to talk about what is going on in my mind.
I really hadn't thought of some of these issues in depth, but when I read them, knowing what I know about agriculture and how we do things today, it rang very true and made sense.
Beekeeping has changed.
![]() |
| Photo Credit: rogercarr |
In the wild, a bee forages on whatever is blooming at the time within about a 2 mile radius of the hive. They can travel further, but 2 miles is the norm. And because different flowers and plants are blooming at different times during the year, bees have a varied diet over the course of a season.
Having this varied diet is good for bees just like it's good for you. Different plants produce different nutrients. And bees need more than one or two nutrients. You wouldn't eat donuts 365 days a year, would you? (Please tell me no!).
In the past, farmers grew a variety of crops and sold them locally. Farms adjacent to each other, might grow totally different crops. My husband's grandparents mainly grew potatoes and tomatoes, but other farmers near by grew carrots and other crops. So within a couple of miles, there was variety. And the bees had their nutritional needs met whether they were wild or kept in a hive box.
![]() |
| Photo Credit: Richard Johnstone |
Today, farming is much different. Monocrops cover the countryside with very little to break up the landscape. Acres upon acres of single plant crops and orchards cover miles of territory so that bees see only one cultivated crop at a time. And with the widespread use of pesticides, native plants (and weeds) are almost non-existent in these same areas.
It's true that beekeepers truck their bees to different areas of the country depending on what needs pollinating at that time (it seems to have worked well for both beekeeper and farmer - in the short run), but keep in mind that a worker bee who forages for the colony only lives 4 - 6 weeks. So during a particular bee's lifespan, it will only forage on one or two crops if it's working for a beekeeper who services the agriculture industry.
Are you starting to form this picture in your mind? Do you see any problems with this?
Since the worker bee feeds the bee "babies", they ( the worker bees) are passing on the nutrients brought back into the hive to the babies. If there is only one crop for a diet, that is all the babies get. And if that crop is high in one nutrient, but low in another, that new baby bee will be deficient in whatever that crop is lacking.
A lack of nutrients means weak bees with suppressed immune systems. A weak immune system means a bee susceptible to things like Varroa mites, nosema, bacteria, fungi, viruses, and the list goes on and on. It can also mean bees with deformities. And if the cycle continues through several generations (which is one season), imagine the stress on a hive during that time.
Any wild thoughts running through your mind yet? Things like Colony Collapse Disorder?
Now I want to say a word here about monocrops. I've not studied the history of the emergence of monocrops, but one can probably assume that it came about as a result of simple economics - supply and demand. Or would that be demand and supply in this case? Oh, that it would have been out of the noble desire to feed the world, but I seriously doubt it. It's more likely that the world wanted cheap food to feed themselves. And Americans have been happy to accomodate.
Farmers who have succumbed to the monocrop practice are not evil and not greedy. They're just trying to make a living. But sometimes we need to look at the way we are doing things and assess whether or not it's working well for us. And if we look at what's happening to our bees (and our chickens, and our cows, and so on and so on...), it's not good. It's really amazing how dependent we are on God's created order, all the way down to the humble, little bee. But that discussion is for another post.
![]() |
| Photo Credit: flickriver.com via Pinterest |
If you have any inclination what-so-ever to keep bees, consider that you can give them a varied diet from your garden, around your property, and in a neighborhood. You probably have more to offer than you realize, and certainly more nutrients than a monocrop!
Tell me your thoughts on this topic! I'm anxious to hear!




The more you talk about bees the more I want my own hive. I am very interested in preserving endangered things. Whether it's a bee, a vegetable or a chicken I hate to see things disappear. Bees are not something we can afford to disappear.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if bats are being affected by the changing agriculture. Bats are also hugely important to the ecosystem.
My thought is if bees are being affected by spray crops and non-diverse crops, maybe bats are too. They eat the insects that are being killed by the insecticides.
I just read an article about an unexplained disease that is affecting bats in parts of the US called White-nose Syndrome. I am wondering if this is agriculture related.
Something to think about.
I bet you're right! I use to see bats flying at night all the time, especially as a kid. But now, there are less and less bats. It's scary what we're doing to ourselves when we mess so much with the ecosystem!
ReplyDeleteThat orchard pic looks exactly like the almond orchards around here. February is a beautiful time. I keep a variety in my garden and have noticed bees buzzing around the wildflowers more than anything else.
ReplyDeleteGreat post! We're looking to have some bees this year - my Father-In-Law has a hive and can help us with it. I swear that a daily dose of local honey (in my coffee) helps with my seasonal allergies.
ReplyDeleteWOW! Very eye opening. I have several friends who keep bees and now I feel I must do my part too! I am new to your blog and I can't thank you enough for all that you share.
ReplyDeleteHi Amy, I really enjoyed listening to your interview. I share a lot of similar ways of eating foods that God intended,"if God made it eat it but if man messed with it stay away"!!
ReplyDeleteAnd growing our own garden and such.
We love our bees and I thought maybe you would enjoy looking at: http://thebuttryandbookry.blogspot.com/2010/10/buzz-on-more-honey-beeeez.html
(a post I did about when we ordered more bees);-)
A book that I have that I really loved is:
The Art and Adventure of Beekeeping by Ormond Aebi. (It's out of print but There are many at used book sites that carry it). Do you have it?
My Husband is a pastor too! And I am so Thankful to God for all His provisions and goodness!
Your Friend in Christ, Linnie
You posts are so informative, I love reading them and learn so much!
ReplyDeleteI agree this is scary! This is why people need to start growing their own food and wean themselves off the machine.:) I have thought of keeping my own bees. This has given me more food to think about urban bee keeping some more.
ReplyDeleteCaroline
So, sounds to me like homesteaders are now playing/will continue to play a huge part in saving the bee...given that most homesteaders are striving for self sufficiency & therefore growing a variety of crops on their properties, rather than the commercial/big farmers tendency to plant monocrops. Even more motivation to get a hive going on our property (haven't convinced hubby yet).
ReplyDeleteIt is scary and thanks for bringing attention to the situation. I have a hive and not only do they produce great tasting honey, but when you eat local honey it helps with any allergies you may have. Honey is very beneficial. I have a small garden that they help pollenate and am working on a flower garden for them to forage from. Take a tablespoon of honey and mix it with apple cider vinegar every moring. Good stuff!
ReplyDeleteMy favorite part of any day is to sit and watch my girls dance and play in the sunshine. The sun just bounces and sparkles off their wings. It is a sight to see. I enjoy them so much I am getting another hive next week! I reccommend them to everyone. Just be careful and respect them as you would anything else.
So many of my friends are starting to grow their own food and raise bees, too!!! I like what you wrote here and am looking forward to your adventures in beekeeping :) Love and hugs from Oregon, Heather :)
ReplyDeleteTalk about a light bulb moment! We have been toying around with the idea of getting a hive. We have bees in a hive in the trunk of our large catalpa tree. We can't access the honey (drat!), but we enjoy seeing them pollinate our flowers and plants.
ReplyDeleteLove, love your blog! Still trying to get caught up on all the past posts! Phew!
Blessings!
Carmen
Old House Kitchen
Thank you for your thoughtful assessment of the honey bee issue. I, too, have been concerned about what we may be doing to our bees. If the bees disappear, we are all in trouble. I really enjoy your writing. Keep it up!
ReplyDeleteWonderful post. As a second generation beekeeper I am eager to learn all I can about my bees. We currently have 3 hives but only 1 made it through the winter- we checked yesterday. Thanks for the post, it all makes so much sense and I've never heard or considered monocrops affecting the bees. I will be getting my hands on the book as soon as it gets in at my library.
ReplyDeleteThis makes so much sense. Life is about balance, for bees and people. When life gets out of balance, that's when we are weakened and more prone to get sick. Thank you for bringing this to our attention.
ReplyDeleteI agree. I am looking forward to the day of having my own hive, but unfortunately right now we live in a very suburban area and my neighbors would not be very cool with it (they already think we're crazy for digging up half of the yard to turn into a garden). I think it's very important that more attention gets brought to what's going on with the bees especially when they effect our whole food supply!
ReplyDeleteDo you think this also effects the flavor of the honey? Our neighbor put bees in the middle of a soybean field last year, and the honey is not very good. I am hoping that the larger garden I am planting this year will help draw the bees. I am also planting more flowers. I guess we will see how the honey is effected.
ReplyDeleteI really enjoy your blog!
Enjoying these posts- we'd like to do bees this year, but don't know if we will fit them in. We've worried about the effects GMO alfalfa will have on them, but this was actually encouraging to think about a varied beed diet. Thanks!
ReplyDeleteI have to get that book! I think you are so right one, while my garden was varied and there was lots of things growing around me, I think if I drew a circle in a two mile radius I would find that there wasn't enough food to sustain them. It makes me sad. I live in a very urban area now that once was farm land. While my land is used as farm land, the land around me lies fallow or has houses on it.
ReplyDeleteI think I would have to agree with your thoughts. Thanks for sharing.
THANK YOU!! I've always wanted to have bees. I asked a friend once, who had a hive, if he wanted some flowers from my garden for his yard, for his bees. He replied, "Oh no. Bees only go to one type of blossom..." At the time, I thought that was strange. It made no sense to me, but I figured he knew what he was talking about. That Winter, his bees died. When I do get bees, (and I will) you can be sure they will have a multitude of blooms to choose from!
ReplyDeleteEva, yes, it should affect the taste of the honey. Honey has a variety of flavors and nuances, just like wine.
ReplyDeleteFarmgirl, lots of people raise bees in urban areas, so I think you're probably okay. But keep gardening!
The mega farmers are the greedy ones, crushing family farms in their path. Then there's the GMO's with pesticide right in the plants. What is that doing to the entire insect population? We need our pollinators!
ReplyDeleteAs far as the food supply, Monsanto is trying to corner the market for the entire food supply patenting natural seeds and then perverting them into GMO's. Buy their one time seed, use their Roundup spray, buy more one time seed next year. All brought to you by Monsanto. Then there's President Obama, approving GMO alfalfa and GMO sugar beets in the last few weeks. Wake up America!
Great topic! It caught my eye because I had just picked up that book @ the library the other day, after attending my first beekeeping meeting with the local county association. I'm hooked already and don't even know what I'm getting into yet. A few years ago, the first and last time I used Sevin Dust on my potatoes (because I didn't know any better) to get rid of some pests, I thought, "wait a minute, if this kills the pest, it will kill the bees!". So I never touched it again, but it didn't occur to me until AFTER I had done it.
ReplyDeleteIt's good to BEE learning.
I found this fascinating Amy. I had never considered beekeeping until I read your blog (of course since we get the bees trucked in each year for the ironbark blossoms & free honey I didn't have to). But since reading & since having the bees here this year, I really would like to look into it. I really miss the buzz of the bees that were everywhere whenever I went outside when we had them on our place.
ReplyDeleteGreat post - thank you
Renata:)
My Fruitless Fall just arrived and I can't wait to start reading!
ReplyDeleteThank you for sharing.
Love your bee pictures! I used to keep bees, but gave it up because of all the diseases and medications needed to help them survive. I miss them very much. So nice to know there are others still doing it.
ReplyDeleteCindy