• You can grow food in any location; soil conditions are no longer an issue.
• Compaction of soil is not as great and thus boxes are easier to work.
• Soil tends to drain better.
• Raised beds warm up a bit faster than the ground in spring allowing you to get a slight jump on the season.
• Season extenders are easier to install if needed.
• Weeds are less of an issue and easier to remove.
• Virtually eliminates gophers, moles, voles, etc.
• Water can be concentrated in a specific area.
• More produce productivity per square foot.
• Less bending over! (Or rather, not bending over as far.)
• Gardeners can create pleasing geometrical arrangements and designs with boxes.
By now you may be wondering if there are there any negatives to this because it sounds too good to be true. Yes, there are a few, but not many...
• Raised beds are an investment - typically about $100 per 4' x 6' box.
• Raised beds must be replaced periodically - beds made of redwood last about 10 years.
• Once in place and filled with soil, they are difficult to move (I wouldn't suggest it!).
• The soil must be amended regularly or it will become depleted of nutrients.
• If you need or desire to garden on a really large scale, boxes can seem a bit limiting.
• Some larger crops, such as potatoes, corn, and squash, can seem to take over a box if not well planned.
| Early Spring Plantings |
Despite a few minor negatives, raised bed gardening really is appealing. Years ago, I lived where the soil was rock hard - lots of clay. Planting anything required a jack hammer - literally! It was very discouraging gardening until I tried raised beds. At the time, I didn't research raised beds and I just had my husband build some wood frames about 6 inches high, stuck them where I wanted, filled them with dirt, and started gardening. And it worked!
When we moved to our current homestead, I spent some time learning about what I really should be doing and found out that a 12 inch deep box was better. (Some of mine are actually 18 inches deep, but they don't work any better than my 12 inch deep boxes.) In order to defray some of the cost over time, I just add one or two new boxes each year.
| Early Summer Crops |
| Frost blanket protection from a light frost. |
Making Raised Beds
Materials:
20 feet of redwood boards of 2" x 12"
48 inches of redwood posts 4" x 4" (these can be smaller if you desire)
4' x 6.5' piece of chicken wire (or hardware cloth)
Wood screws
Staple Gun
Directions:
Cut the 20' board down to two 6' lengths and two 4' lengths. Cut the redwood post into four 12" lengths. Assemble following pattern below and using wood screws to attach the longer boards to the square posts.
Your box will not be exactly 4' x 6' when you're done, but doing it this way reduces your costs a bit by purchase the least amount of wood and by having less waste due to extra cuts. So in the end, your box will be a little longer than 6' and a little narrower than 4'. And this is why your chicken wire needs to be at least 6 1/2 feet long.
| Example of 1.5" x 1.5" corner supports. |
| Example of 4" x 4" corner supports. |
Finally, attach the chicken wire to the bottom of the frame you have just made using your staple gun. Flip the box over and place it wherever you desire! If you're placing the boxes on a grass or a weed infested area, just lay down some newspaper first, then your box, and start filling it with gardening soil. The newspaper will kill the weeds and grass over time and then eventually compost into the soil underneath.
Oh, and if you want to add irrigation, be sure to do so before you add your soil. Just go underneath the box with your pvc pipe and up through the chicken wire. I added a faucet to mine and I attach a soaker hose to it.
Q and A
• Can you make the beds any size you want? Absolutely, but anything over 4 feet wide will make it difficult to reach the center when you want to weed, prune, or harvest.
• What about length? Length isn't so much of an issue, but if you get the beds too long, the boards will need more support in the center to prevent them from bowing out. Eight feet is about the max you want to go.
• You said you had 18 inch deep boxes. Isn't that better? Yes and no. Yes for root veggies, although they will work down through the wire on the 12" boxes if necessary, but when you make the 18" deep boxes, you'll have to use more than one board on the side going up. This not only costs more, but you lose water from between the boards; this is why I spend the money on the 12" boards instead of two 6" boards when making my boxes now. (You can see from my photos I've tried both). The cons of the 18" deep outweigh the pros in this situation.
• Can you use any kind of wood? Not if you want your boxes to last. You'll need a material that can stand up to rotting for as long as possible. Do not use treated lumber because it will leech chemicals into your soil and produce. Around here, it is common to pick up railroad ties for free, but they're treated with creosote and you don't want to have that in your beds. Redwood or cedar naturally resists bugs and will not rot quickly. If your boxes last 10 years, your annual cost should not exceed $10 per box. This is another reason why I staggered building mine; they shouldn't all need replacing at the same time and thus become cost prohibitive.
• Do the corner supports have to be 4" square? No. They are extra sturdy like this, but it's not necessary. I've done different sizes.
| Sugar Snap Peas |
| Zucchini |
| Tomato Plants |
• What do you fill your boxes with? I have done this two ways. I've used a bagged organic potting soil that I purchased from a local nursery and I've also done the lasagna method right in the box where I layer some potting soil, amendments, some dirt from my yard, and compost. Sometimes I till it in and other times, I just layer it up. Both seem to work. And at the end of the season, when I let my chickens into the garden, they till it all up for me again!
There are so many great things to say about raised beds, so I think this topic deserves some more posts. And perhaps in the fall when I have some more photos and I've worked on my season extenders, I can show you some of that, too. A little at a time, right? Today is the first warm day outside and I can hardly wait for the weekend to get out there and get some stuff done! Pray the weather holds!
Have you gardened with raised beds? Please share any tips you can add!



Great post!! Makes me want to try raised bed gardening. Maybe next year?? Hope you enjoy your day outside.
ReplyDeleteHave a God Filled Day
Shirley
We have our frames ready to go, but need to fill with soil. This is my first time and very excited. Our frames are recycled 4x4 pallet stackers that were already hinged at the corners. Perfect. We painted to match our chicken coop. I have not yet decided what to plant, yet.
ReplyDeleteRaised beds are my favorite way to garden. Been doing it for years. When we first started putting them in, people would stop on the gravel road behind our house to ask what we were doing. Great post and advice!
ReplyDeleteCindy
I would love to have some raised beds,but right now can't afford to. Your vegs look very pretty. So for now I will continue to simply plant in our garden.Blessings jane
ReplyDeleteAll of our gardening is done in raised beds. Living in AL, we have hard as rock, red clay soil and like you, would have needed a jackhammer to do any kind of planting. The first year we started out with two beds, the following year three more were added and now there is a total of 8 large beds and 2 small beds. We get compost every spring to top dress and this year I will experiment covering everything with a layer of straw. So far, so good... :-)
ReplyDeleteThank you for posting this. I am living in the small city life and will be doing raised beds for the first time this year. I really like the way that you do your peas. I am looking for lots of tips and this really helps. Would love more gardening posts!
ReplyDeleteHi Amy!
ReplyDeleteI've been enjoying your blog for some time now.
My husband just completed building 12-4x8 raised beds for our garden this year and had 2 dumptruck loads of rich, black soil delivered to our very rocky, clay South Carolina mountain land. I wrote a post about that the other day, and was going to follow up today on the benefits of why we chose raised beds, but think I'll simply link that upcoming post to yours as "you took the words right out of my mouth" (fingers?!) You are right, raised beds are very expensive, particularly the way we are doing by also buying the dirt, but we consider this an "investment" in our future not only in healthy eating, but in healthy living and responsibility of taking care of oneself. Thank you again.
Lisa
So much good information! Thanks for sharing. And happy gardening to you! Blessings, ~Lisa
ReplyDeleteThis is a great post! It's especially good info for people who want to garden food in a small yard space. We are blessed to have lots of bamboo around us that we can use free to make our box frames.
ReplyDeleteIs there a reason you recommend 4x6 boxes when most lumber comes in 92 or 96 inch length? The most economical sizes seem to be 4x4 and 4x8 feet.
ReplyDeletelast year we did a raised bed in our tiny yard in brooklyn. our garden was boxed in by our garage and the neighbor's so we only had to do up one side to make a box- we used cinderblocks (they were free from some construction down the road) and just newspapered the grass inside then soiled.
ReplyDeleteI am totally sold on the idea of box gardening as we produced so much last year, if i did it the "right" way i can see no limits to how much we could produce!
This year we are trying to do direct gardening since we have the space, but as the season goes on and the grass is still in the yard i lean further and further towards two boxes....
We also used raised beds and have a mixture of 4 x 4' and 4 x 8' ones. (The smaller ones were our first "trial" ones; we now use larger ones.) We add a couple more each year as well. This year, we're making them out of concrete block rather than wood, figuring it's longer-lasting and could maybe be moved if needed. In our first 3 boxes, we used the Mel's Mix recommended in Square Foot Gardening, but since then have gotten away from using anything to make squares and have filled the other boxes with a mix of peat, our topsoil, whatever compost we have ready, and bunny manure.
ReplyDeleteWe were blessed to buy property with raised beds already set up in the backyard (filled with waist high weeds). We've added a few more beds and now are having to repair and replace some of the original ones, as they are at least 15 years old. I agree that there are many pros to raised beds. Our ground soil is very hard clay and would be impossible to dig and till. Thanks for sharing your ideas.
ReplyDeleteWe move to our little farm on April 13 and I've already warned my family that the weekend after, whether or not everything inside is unpacked, I will be outside putting in our garden. I have all the plans laid out, supply list for lumber and seedlings already to go in the ground.
ReplyDeleteWonderful and informative post Amy! We are doing at least 4 raised beds this year! I'm book marking this one for sure!
ReplyDeleteDeb
Nice...it all looks so lovely. The photos made me excited for the growing season...but NOT excited for the hot weather...not ready for that yet!!
ReplyDeleteAmy 20 years ago we had the raised beds.My hubbie stapled plastic lining along the inside where the two boards came together.This was so we wouldn't have water leakaged. It worked pretty well.We also put pvc in the corners....so we could put up cold frames.We just stuck the pvc frame into the corner pvc.I do agree....anything over 4 ft is soooo hard to manage without crawling in it.
ReplyDeleteCindy from Rick-Rack and Gingham
Here in Florida, where much of the "soil" is just glorified beach sand, raised bed gardens are about the only way to go. By eliminating the sand that "root knot" nematodes thrive in, we have avoided the number-one problem we had with our in-ground gardens of the past.
ReplyDeleteI recently built what I call "my raised bed garden on steroids". It is built using concrete blocks, and is high enough that I can comfortably sit on the edge to work in the garden. Our goal was to have something that will be easy and enjoyable to work in when our backs no longer tolerate bending over.
Having it as deep as it is meant paying for pallets of potting soil, but this is a long term project. We see it as a permanent part of the house - just as we have a water system and an electrical system, we also have a food production system.
Here are photos of our raised bed garden being built.
Stephen Clay McGehee
SouthernAgrarian.com
Thank you for posting this. I am new here (never commented before), but am loving your blog. I've gardened in raised beds for 15 years now. We live in the foothills of the Rocky Mountains where there is no soil, just rock and crushed rock, even native grasses don't grow well here; raised beds are a must for us.
ReplyDeleteAt first my beds were 8" deep, when those rotted (just plain pine boards) we did without and wood sides, just mounded the dirt in lasagna garden style. This year we are rebuilding the beds with redwood, 18" deep, just like you show, but extending the 4x4 legs down into the ground to allow us to be able to level the bed as our garden is on a slope. I'm filling them lasagna style as that has proven to produce the best gardens for me.
If you have time to answer, I'd like to know what the metal grid is in the first picture. You have it at an angle, are you going to grow something up it or will you put shade cloth over it for your summer lettuces? Also, when you let your chickens in, don't they make a big mess of the raised beds, kicking lots of the dirt out?
Thanks again for your blog. I am encouraged and appreciate having a place where I can go to learn more about these things. God bless you and your family!
Great post! We live in the Denver area - talk about clay and bunnies. We've had good luck with raised beds. It looks like you're using the square foot gardening method too? For folks new to raised bed gardening I recommend the book "Square Foot Gardening" by Mel Bartholomew.
ReplyDeleteFor those of us located in the South then old growth heart pine might be a a good alternative wood option as opposed to redwood or cedar. This is different than Loblolly pine. It must be old growth heart pine, which is very dense and will generally last a long time. It can sometimes be hard to find as nowadays it is almost endangered, but the sandhills of NC and SC are full of it. You can find tons of old outbuildings that were never painted still standing strong made of old growth heart pine because it was the most readily available local wood.
ReplyDeleteOur garden is o.k....nothing special. It's certainly not as productive as it could be. I think I may show hubby this post. You have inspired me once again! : )
ReplyDeletejimmycrackedcorn - we made our boxes 4 x 6 because it fit our space well, a 20 ft. board could be easily cut to size, and lumber prices. It's been a couple of years, so I'm going on my memory, but if I remember correctly, the cost was better this way. Keep in mind that different lumber yards may do things differently (we buy at a mom and pop place) and where you live might make a difference as well. I'll be the first to agree that it may be better to do it differently than we've done it, but this has worked really well for us.
ReplyDeleteSpencer Mom - yes, that metal grid thing is for my cucumbers; they were to grow up that and shade the lettuce as the summer heat came on.
Jenn, I've read most of Mel's book, and I used the lathe board the first year, but it was frustrating to work around it, so I ripped it off. I'll be showing an alternative to the lathe board for those who want to garden by the foot next week (hopefully). Also, Mel uses fairly shallow boxes; I agree with Ed Smith of The Vegetable Gardener's Bible, that deep beds are better.
Amy, in 2 of the pics you have some fencing at an angle over the bed. Is that for climbing plants? Thanks!
ReplyDeleteI used cement blocks for mine so I will never have to replace them!
ReplyDeletegreat post...I have been wanting to do this for some time...maybe I haven't waited to late to get started for this season...
ReplyDeleteThanks for all the info.
Shug
Shelly, yes, that is for climbing plants - cucumbers in particular.
ReplyDeleteShug, I don't know your growing season, but in my Zone 7, I am just starting cooler spring crops outside and warm crops indoors.
My veggie beds are raised, constructed from cinder blocks. I wouldn't recommend expensive potting soil. My combination is Amend, peat moss and sand with my native, no good, rotten, clay soil.
ReplyDeleteWhat a great post! I have been toying with the idea of raised beds and with your tutorial, it sounds very doable.
ReplyDeleteThanks!
~ Tracy
Hi Amy!
ReplyDeleteGreat information. I'm especially glad that you showed pictures of your cold frames. This is the first year for us to do raised beds-- so far I'm loving it!
I really like the ALMOST WEEDLESS part. I go out everyday and take out what little bit of weeds I may see; but there virtually are none. (only a little every so often.
I like having the uppper hand on the weeds, and on placement of my plants. each bed is different varieties of plants. So far it is so good.
I love reading your site too, btw. You're an informative writer.
That's what I'm always looking for when on the net...good information!
~Pat
Soon the snow will be gone and I can see the garden area. Then I can start building the raised bed garden frames. When hubby and I got married he had 4 4x8 raised beds, with money we got as a wedding present we made 3 more and one 12x4. We never thought of putting fencing on the bottom, we just dug out the hole, 2 shovel depth deep and turned soil by hand, then we mulched it all, then moved the mulch to plant the plants, had drip irrigation also. Only watered about once a month except when plants first go in then nightly. Mulch held in the moisture but not too much. In South NJ it gets very warm in the summer, but the garden did fine, except for the ground hogs who loved the buffet we planted just for them (so they thought)Letting the dogs out most of the day took care of that problem though. We had a fenced in yard and the ground hogs would get in every way possible until they got chased by the dogs, then they became a tad more scarce.
ReplyDeleteAdele
I only have one question- how do you keep the birds out? We have grackles here. They're awful. I've been putting off planting anything, thinking that I'm just wasting my time; the birds will eat it all.
ReplyDeleteGreat post! When we purchased our farmhouse I decided we needed to go with raised beds. Our soil was AWFUL! My dearest husband built the beds and I ordered a mix of dirt/compost from a local farm to be delivered. I love the boxes. I also had him build 2 counter-top height mesclun boxes so no animals could get to them and so it's easier to plant and pick since I re-seed the bed continuously.
ReplyDeleteStaci
Last year I read Steve Solomon's Gardening When It Counts & he discouraged raised beds because they typically don't give roots the access to nutrients they would have if you planted them directly in the ground.
ReplyDeleteAnd while they look pretty and are neat, might want to be reconsidered unless you have "special needs" ground like rocks, etc.. But for your average ground (like mine is) planting regularly is the way to go for optimum nutrient density in your vegetables.
That said, I do have a few for root crops like carrots that don't do well in our soil that leans toward clay and also for crops that will get season extenders like greens & brassicas.
I reviewed the whole book here:
http://onjustacoupleacres.blogspot.com/2010/04/my-thoughts-on-gardening-when-it-counts.html
Fantastic post, thank you for taking the time to educate us and to share your beautiful pics.
ReplyDeletePeace and Raw Health,
Elizabeth
Sandy, I use bird netting. I just drape it over and hook it on some nails on the side, but this year, I'm adding some electrical conduit hoops as frames. These will remain in place to be ready to extend the harvest.
ReplyDeleteQuinn, Thanks for the information. I think I've heard that before, but I haven't read his book to know why he thinks that the roots can't access the soil below the box. I'll read your post for sure.
ReplyDeleteI have a rather icky question. We put in a garden a few years ago and planted it for a year or two. But things were really busy and I didn't make the garden a priority the last 2 years. In the mean time.... our dog decided to "use it" for his choice poop area. So I know I should have FENCED it in.
ReplyDeleteBut my question is what do I do now? Do I dig and sift all the dirt or what. Can't imagine that dog poop is okay in the garden since you can't compost it.
Help... what are your suggestions(besides the fence)for the poop that is in there now.
Hi Ginna. Well, seems like roundworms could be an issue for up to 10 years. The little bit of research I did doesn't sound good. Read here: http://www.extension.umn.edu/yardandgarden/ygbriefs/h238manure-dog-cat.html
ReplyDeleteNow you've got me to thinking because before we put our fence up across a portion of the yard, my dog used that area some. Hmmmm.... I wonder how we'd know if we had round worms. If I think about this much I might freak out! Trying to stay calm...
Amy, I loved the pics of your garden! We have been using a larger (4x16) raised bed for a few years. I planned to add another, but instead, we decided to improve ours by making it deeper. I wish you had written this 2 weeks ago, because we just stacked our boards to make it deeper. HA! Planting happens tomorrow! Compost bin goes in tomorrow, as well. Yay Spring!
ReplyDeleteGreat point, in his book, he has drawings of each root system showing a depth of a million feet deep (it was surprising how deep some plants go!) When I pulled up my tomatoes this year I was surprised to see that the roots went 6 feet straight out from the plant! Maybe he meant vertically, I can't remember.
ReplyDeleteI was tired when I posted last night and really should add that his main point against raised bed was that it lends itself to intensive gardening which doesn't give each plant enough room and they have to compete in that space for nutrients.
I just want to say also that I LOVE, LOVE, LOVE your attitude about compost- so very biblical, so very freeing. (Especially since our pile is not doing as well as I had hoped after a year and I was beginning to get anxious about it.) Thanks :)
Thank you so much for sharing how you build a raised bed! I have a huge garden, but cannot grow tomatoes in it due to septoria leaf spot which is a fungus in the soil. I have tried for years to get rid of it and protect my tomatoes from it, but it never works. So, this year I am going to build a raised bed for my tomatoes and with your tutorial it will be SO easy! Thanks!
ReplyDeleteGreat post, I also love gardening in raised beds, much easier to weed, and tend. I have a very small yard, and I put rasied beds along the sunny side of my yard and grow quite a large amount of fresh veggies. Great step by step instructions- it makes me want to squeeze a few more in my garden!!
ReplyDeleteAmy, thanks for the link about dog poo. I did read it and may do some checking on my own. I am just so reluctant to do anything about the soil. I am fencing the area but not sure if there is any hope of a garden this year. I need to figure out what I will do this year and work on it now and through the winter. Thanks. Love you blog
ReplyDeleteAmy, thank you so much! I had never heard of bird netting. Can you tell how much of a beginner I am? Big sigh of relief over here, now I can go forth and plant!
ReplyDeleteThanks for the post mate you have written it very well.
ReplyDeleteOne thing I'm wondering is why use the 4x4's? Would the beds not be solid without them? Or are they strictly to hold the boards firm so they don't warp?
ReplyDeleteHi Josh,
DeleteWe are still using corner supports, just not 4 x 4. Something smaller. But it definitely gives additional support to those corners. My husband likes to do things extra sturdy. :-)